Boundary Layer Transition and Surface Roughness Effects in Hypersonic Flow

Download Boundary Layer Transition and Surface Roughness Effects in Hypersonic Flow PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 90 pages
Book Rating : 4.3/5 (91 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Boundary Layer Transition and Surface Roughness Effects in Hypersonic Flow by : Michael S. Holden

Download or read book Boundary Layer Transition and Surface Roughness Effects in Hypersonic Flow written by Michael S. Holden and published by . This book was released on 1981 with total page 90 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt:

Effects of Surface Roughness on Boundary Layer Transition in a Hypersonic Flow

Download Effects of Surface Roughness on Boundary Layer Transition in a Hypersonic Flow PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (111 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Effects of Surface Roughness on Boundary Layer Transition in a Hypersonic Flow by : Oliver Taylor

Download or read book Effects of Surface Roughness on Boundary Layer Transition in a Hypersonic Flow written by Oliver Taylor and published by . This book was released on 2018 with total page pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt:

Studies of Boundary Layer Transition and Surface Roughness Effects in Hypersonic Flow: Final Report Covering Period 1 November 1978 - 30 September 1982

Download Studies of Boundary Layer Transition and Surface Roughness Effects in Hypersonic Flow: Final Report Covering Period 1 November 1978 - 30 September 1982 PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 296 pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (648 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Studies of Boundary Layer Transition and Surface Roughness Effects in Hypersonic Flow: Final Report Covering Period 1 November 1978 - 30 September 1982 by : Michael S. Holden

Download or read book Studies of Boundary Layer Transition and Surface Roughness Effects in Hypersonic Flow: Final Report Covering Period 1 November 1978 - 30 September 1982 written by Michael S. Holden and published by . This book was released on 1983 with total page 296 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt:

A Numerical Study of 2-D Surface Roughness Effects on the Growth of Wave Modes in Hypersonic Boundary Layers

Download A Numerical Study of 2-D Surface Roughness Effects on the Growth of Wave Modes in Hypersonic Boundary Layers PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 219 pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (17 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis A Numerical Study of 2-D Surface Roughness Effects on the Growth of Wave Modes in Hypersonic Boundary Layers by : Kahei Danny Fong

Download or read book A Numerical Study of 2-D Surface Roughness Effects on the Growth of Wave Modes in Hypersonic Boundary Layers written by Kahei Danny Fong and published by . This book was released on 2017 with total page 219 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: The current understanding and research efforts on surface roughness effects in hypersonic boundary-layer flows focus, almost exclusively, on how roughness elements trip a hypersonic boundary layer to turbulence. However, there were a few reports in the literature suggesting that roughness elements in hypersonic boundary-layer flows could sometimes suppress the transition process and delay the formation of turbulent flow. These reports were not common and had not attracted much attention from the research community. Furthermore, the mechanisms of how the delay and stabilization happened were unknown. A recent study by Duan et al. showed that when 2-D roughness elements were placed downstream of the so-called synchronization point, the unstable second-mode wave in a hypersonic boundary layer was damped. Since the second-mode wave is typically the most dangerous and dominant unstable mode in a hypersonic boundary layer for sharp geometries at a zero angle of attack, this result has pointed to an explanation on how roughness elements delay transition in a hypersonic boundary layer. Such an understanding can potentially have significant practical applications for the development of passive flow control techniques to suppress hypersonic boundary-layer transition, for the purpose of aero-heating reduction. Nevertheless, the previous study was preliminary because only one particular flow condition with one fixed roughness parameter was considered. The study also lacked an examination on the mechanism of the damping effect of the second mode by roughness. Hence, the objective of the current research is to conduct an extensive investigation of the effects of 2-D roughness elements on the growth of instability waves in a hypersonic boundary layer. The goal is to provide a full physical picture of how and when 2-D roughness elements stabilize a hypersonic boundary layer. Rigorous parametric studies using numerical simulation, linear stability theory (LST), and parabolized stability equation (PSE) are performed to ensure the fidelity of the data and to study the relevant flow physics. All results unanimously confirm the conclusion that the relative location of the synchronization point with respect to the roughness element determines the roughness effect on the second mode. Namely, a roughness placed upstream of the synchronization point amplifies the unstable waves while placing a roughness downstream of the synchronization point damps the second-mode waves. The parametric study also shows that a tall roughness element within the local boundary-layer thickness results in a stronger damping effect, while the effect of the roughness width is relatively insignificant compared with the other roughness parameters. On the other hand, the fact that both LST and PSE successfully predict the damping effect only by analyzing the meanflow suggests the mechanism of the damping is by the meanflow alteration due to the existence of roughness elements, rather than new mode generation. In addition to studying the unstable waves, the drag force and heating with and without roughness have been investigated by comparing the numerical simulation data with experimental correlations. It is shown that the increase in drag force generated by the Mach wave around a roughness element in a hypersonic boundary layer is insignificant compared to the reduction of drag force by suppressing turbulent flow. The study also shows that, for a cold wall flow which is the case for practical flight applications, the Stanton number decreases as roughness elements smooth out the temperature gradient in the wall-normal direction. Based on the knowledge of roughness elements damping the second mode gained from the current study, a novel passive transition control method using judiciously placed roughness elements has been developed, and patented, during the course of this research. The main idea of the control method is that, with a given geometry and flow condition, it is possible to find the most unstable second-mode frequency that can lead to transition. And by doing a theoretical analysis such as LST, the synchronization location for the most unstable frequency can be found. Roughness elements are then strategically placed downstream of the synchronization point to damp out this dangerous second-mode wave, thus stabilizing the boundary layer and suppressing the transition process. This method is later experimentally validated in Purdue's Mach 6 quiet wind tunnel. Overall, this research has not only provided details of when and how 2-D roughness stabilizes a hypersonic boundary layer, it also has led to a successful application of numerical simulation data to the development of a new roughness-based transition delay method, which could potentially have significant contributions to the design of future generation hypersonic vehicles.

Effects of Unit Reynolds Number, Nose Bluntness, and Roughness on Boundary Layer Transition

Download Effects of Unit Reynolds Number, Nose Bluntness, and Roughness on Boundary Layer Transition PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 166 pages
Book Rating : 4.3/5 (91 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Effects of Unit Reynolds Number, Nose Bluntness, and Roughness on Boundary Layer Transition by : J. Leith Potter

Download or read book Effects of Unit Reynolds Number, Nose Bluntness, and Roughness on Boundary Layer Transition written by J. Leith Potter and published by . This book was released on 1960 with total page 166 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: Condtions encountered in the high Mach number flow regime are show to profoundly affect the longitudinal extent of the boundary layer from beginning to end of transition, the distribution of fluctuation energy in the laminar layer, and effectiveness of surface roughness in promoting transition. A critical layer of intense local energy fluctuations was found at all Mach numbers studied. The existence of such a critical layer is predicted by stability theory. Hot-wire surveys of the laminar, transitional, and turbulent boundary layers are presented to illustrate the critical layer in laminar flow and subsequent development into the transition process. The relation between boundary layer transition on flat plates and cones in supersonic flow is explored and a process for correcting data to account for leading edge bluntness is devised. On the basis of a comparison of data corrected for the effects of leading edge geometry, it is shown that the Reynolds umber of transition on a cone is three times that on a vanishingly thin flate plate. Close agreement between data from various wind tunnels is demonstrated. Study of the effect of finite leading edges yields significant illustrations of the influence of unit Reynolds number on boundary layer transition. A correlation of the effects of surface roughness on transition is achieved. This treatment includes two- and three-dimensional roughness in both subsonic and supersonic streams. At this time only zero pressure gradients have been studied. The entire range of movement of transition from its position with no roughness up to its reaching the roughness element is describable by the procedure give. Examples of application of the correlation results show excellent agreement with experimental data from a variety of sources. Implications concerning tripping hypersonic boundary layers are discussed.

Roughness Effects on Boundary-layer Transition for Blunt-leading-edge Plates at Mach 6

Download Roughness Effects on Boundary-layer Transition for Blunt-leading-edge Plates at Mach 6 PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 52 pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (31 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Roughness Effects on Boundary-layer Transition for Blunt-leading-edge Plates at Mach 6 by : Paul F. Holloway

Download or read book Roughness Effects on Boundary-layer Transition for Blunt-leading-edge Plates at Mach 6 written by Paul F. Holloway and published by . This book was released on 1966 with total page 52 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt:

Roughness, Bluntness, and Angle of Attack Effects on Hypersonic Boundary Layer Transition

Download Roughness, Bluntness, and Angle of Attack Effects on Hypersonic Boundary Layer Transition PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 55 pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (227 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Roughness, Bluntness, and Angle of Attack Effects on Hypersonic Boundary Layer Transition by : H. T. Nagamatsu

Download or read book Roughness, Bluntness, and Angle of Attack Effects on Hypersonic Boundary Layer Transition written by H. T. Nagamatsu and published by . This book was released on 1964 with total page 55 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: An investigation was conducted in a hypersonic shock tunnel to study the laminar boundary layer transition on a highly cooled 10-degree cone of 4-foot length over the Mach number range of 8.5 to 10.5 with a stagnation temperature of 1400K. The effects on transition of tip surface roughness, tip bluntness, and =2-degree angle of attack were investigated. With fast response thin film surface heat transfer gauges, it was possible to detect the passage of turbulent bursts that appeared at the beginning of transition. It was found that the surface roughness greatly promoted transition in the proper Reynolds number range. The Reynolds number for the beginning and end of transition at the 8.5 Mach number location were 3,800,000 to 9,600,000 and 2,200,000 to 4,200,000 for the smooth sharp tip and rough sharp tip, respectively. The local skin friction data agreed with the heat transfer data through Reynolds analogy. The tip bluntness data showed a strong delay in the beginning of transition for a cone base to tip diameter ratio of 20, approximately a 35% increase in Reynolds number over that of the smooth sharp tip case. The angle of attack data indicated the cross flow to have a strong influence on transition by promoting it on the sheltered side of the cone and delaying it on the windward side. (Author).

Transition Fixing for Hypersonic Flow

Download Transition Fixing for Hypersonic Flow PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 28 pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (31 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Transition Fixing for Hypersonic Flow by :

Download or read book Transition Fixing for Hypersonic Flow written by and published by . This book was released on 1967 with total page 28 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt:

Comments on Hypersonic Boundary-layer Transition

Download Comments on Hypersonic Boundary-layer Transition PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 116 pages
Book Rating : 4.3/5 (91 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Comments on Hypersonic Boundary-layer Transition by : Kenneth F. Stetson

Download or read book Comments on Hypersonic Boundary-layer Transition written by Kenneth F. Stetson and published by . This book was released on 1990 with total page 116 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: This is a survey paper on the subject of hypersonic boundary-layer transition. Part 1 discusses boundary-layer stability theory, hypersonic boundary-layer stability experiments, and a comparison between theory and experiment. Part 2 contains comments on how many configuration and flow parameters influence transition. Part 3 discusses some additional general aspects of transition. Part 4 discusses problems of predicting transition and comments on three prediction methods. Part 5 contains some general guidelines for prediction methodology. Keywords: Boundary layer transition, Boundary layer stability, Hypersonic boundary layers.

Review of the Effect of Distributed Surface Roughness on Boundary-layer Transition

Download Review of the Effect of Distributed Surface Roughness on Boundary-layer Transition PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 13 pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (177 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Review of the Effect of Distributed Surface Roughness on Boundary-layer Transition by : A. L. Braslow

Download or read book Review of the Effect of Distributed Surface Roughness on Boundary-layer Transition written by A. L. Braslow and published by . This book was released on 1960 with total page 13 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: A discussion is presented on the transition phenomena associated with distributed roughness, a correlation of three-dimensional roughness effects at both subsonic and supersonic speeds, and the effect of laminar boundary-layer stability as influenced by heat transfer, pressure gradients, and boundary-layer control on the sensitivity of laminar flow to distributed roughness. Results indicate that the transition-triggering mechanism of three-dimensionaltype surface roughness appears to be the same at supersonic and subsonic speeds. In either case, a Reynolds number based on the height of the roughness and the local flow conditions at the top of the roughness can be used to predict with reasonable accuracy the height of threedimensional roughness required to cause premature transition. Neither the three-dimensional roughness Reynolds number nor the lateral spread of turbulence behind the roughness is changed to any important extent by increasing the laminar boundary-layer stability to theoretically small disturbances. Therefore, for a given stream Mach number and Reynolds number, surface cooling, boundary-layer suction, or a favorable pressure gradient will, in the presence of three-dimensional roughness, promote rather than delay transition. (Author).

Boundary-layer Transition Under Hypersonic Conditions

Download Boundary-layer Transition Under Hypersonic Conditions PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 128 pages
Book Rating : 4.3/5 (91 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Boundary-layer Transition Under Hypersonic Conditions by : J. Leith Potter

Download or read book Boundary-layer Transition Under Hypersonic Conditions written by J. Leith Potter and published by . This book was released on 1965 with total page 128 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt:

Surface Roughness Effects on the Hypersonic Turbulent Boundary Layer

Download Surface Roughness Effects on the Hypersonic Turbulent Boundary Layer PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 115 pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (227 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Surface Roughness Effects on the Hypersonic Turbulent Boundary Layer by : Dale Evan Berg

Download or read book Surface Roughness Effects on the Hypersonic Turbulent Boundary Layer written by Dale Evan Berg and published by . This book was released on 1977 with total page 115 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: An experimental investigation of the response of a hypersonic turbulent boundary layer to a step change in surface roughness has been performed. The boundary layer on a flat nozzle wall of a Mach 6 wind tunnel was subjected to abrupt changes in surface roughness and its adjustment to the new surface conditions was examined. Both mean and fluctuating flow properties were acquired for smooth-to-rough and rough-to-smooth surface configurations. (Author).

EFFECTS OF COOLING ON TRANSITION IN USE BOUNDARY LAYER ON A HEMISPHERE IN SIMULATED HYPERSONIC FLOW

Download EFFECTS OF COOLING ON TRANSITION IN USE BOUNDARY LAYER ON A HEMISPHERE IN SIMULATED HYPERSONIC FLOW PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 113 pages
Book Rating : 4.3/5 (91 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis EFFECTS OF COOLING ON TRANSITION IN USE BOUNDARY LAYER ON A HEMISPHERE IN SIMULATED HYPERSONIC FLOW by : ROGER DUNLAP

Download or read book EFFECTS OF COOLING ON TRANSITION IN USE BOUNDARY LAYER ON A HEMISPHERE IN SIMULATED HYPERSONIC FLOW written by ROGER DUNLAP and published by . This book was released on 1961 with total page 113 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt:

Effect of Distributed Three-dimensional Roughness and Surface Cooling on Boundary-layer Transition and Lateral Spread of Turbulence at Supersonic Speeds

Download Effect of Distributed Three-dimensional Roughness and Surface Cooling on Boundary-layer Transition and Lateral Spread of Turbulence at Supersonic Speeds PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 48 pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (317 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Effect of Distributed Three-dimensional Roughness and Surface Cooling on Boundary-layer Transition and Lateral Spread of Turbulence at Supersonic Speeds by : Albert L. Braslow

Download or read book Effect of Distributed Three-dimensional Roughness and Surface Cooling on Boundary-layer Transition and Lateral Spread of Turbulence at Supersonic Speeds written by Albert L. Braslow and published by . This book was released on 1959 with total page 48 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt:

Numerical Simulation of Hypersonic Boundary Layer Receptivity, Transient Growth and Transition With Surface Roughness

Download Numerical Simulation of Hypersonic Boundary Layer Receptivity, Transient Growth and Transition With Surface Roughness PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 56 pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (61 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Numerical Simulation of Hypersonic Boundary Layer Receptivity, Transient Growth and Transition With Surface Roughness by :

Download or read book Numerical Simulation of Hypersonic Boundary Layer Receptivity, Transient Growth and Transition With Surface Roughness written by and published by . This book was released on 2009 with total page 56 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: The objective of this research is to conduct DNS studies of hypersonic boundary layer receptivity, transient growth and transition with surface roughness. The main approach is to use DNS as a research tool to study the boundary layer receptivity and transient-growth mechanisms in hypersonic flows, including the development of numerical algorithms and parallel computer codes of higher order numerical methods for the simulation of hypersonic flows with surface roughness of finite heights. During the three-year period, we have conducted DNS studies on the hypersonic boundary layer flows over flat plates and blunt cones. A new high-order cut-cell method has been developed for the numerical simulation of hypersonic boundary layer transition with finite height surface roughness. The method has been applied to the numerical simulations of two-dimensional hypersonic flows over a flat plate. Furthermore, the stabilization effect of the surface porous coating over a flat plate is extensively studied by series of numerical simulations. We also collaborate with Prof. Tumin in the University of Arizona to compare numerical and theoretical results on receptivity of a Mach 5.92 flow over a flat plate to wall blowing-suction, and to analyze the nonparallel flow effect.

Effects of Thermochemical Nonequilibrium on Hypersonic Boundary-Layer Instability in the Presence of Surface Ablation Or Isolated Two-Dimensional Roughness

Download Effects of Thermochemical Nonequilibrium on Hypersonic Boundary-Layer Instability in the Presence of Surface Ablation Or Isolated Two-Dimensional Roughness PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 251 pages
Book Rating : 4.:/5 (17 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Effects of Thermochemical Nonequilibrium on Hypersonic Boundary-Layer Instability in the Presence of Surface Ablation Or Isolated Two-Dimensional Roughness by : Clifton Mortensen

Download or read book Effects of Thermochemical Nonequilibrium on Hypersonic Boundary-Layer Instability in the Presence of Surface Ablation Or Isolated Two-Dimensional Roughness written by Clifton Mortensen and published by . This book was released on 2015 with total page 251 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: The current understanding of the effects of thermochemical nonequilibrium on hypersonic boundary-layer instability still contains uncertainties, and there has been little research into the effects of surface ablation, or two-dimensional roughness, on hypersonic boundary-layer instability. The objective of this work is to study the effects of thermochemical nonequilibrium on hypersonic boundary-layer instability. More specifically, two separate nonequilibrium flow configurations are studied: 1) flows with graphite surface ablation, and 2) flows with isolated two-dimensional surface roughness. These two flow types are studied numerically and theoretically, using direct numerical simulation and linear stability theory, respectively. To study surface ablation, a new high-order shock-fitting method with thermochemical nonequilibrium and finite-rate chemistry boundary conditions for graphite ablation is developed and validated. The method is suitable for direct numerical simulation of boundary-layer transition in a hypersonic real-gas flow with graphite ablation. The new method is validated by comparison with three computational data sets and one set of experimental data. Also, a thermochemical nonequilibrium linear stability theory solver with a gas phase model that includes multiple carbon species, as well as a linearized surface graphite ablation model, is developed and validated. It is validated with previously published linear stability analysis and direct numerical simulation results. A high-order method for discretizing the linear stability equations is used which can easily include high-order boundary conditions. The developed codes are then used to study hypersonic boundary-layer instability for a 7 deg half angle blunt cone at Mach 15.99 and the Reentry F experiment at 100~kft. Multiple simulations are run with the same geometry and freestream conditions to help separate real gas, blowing, and carbon species effects on hypersonic boundary-layer instability. For the case at Mach 15.99, a directly simulated 525~kHz second-mode wave was found to be significantly unstable for the real-gas simulation, while in the ideal-gas simulations, no significant flow instability is seen. An N factor comparison also shows that real-gas effects significantly destabilize the flow when compared to an ideal gas. Blowing is destabilizing for the real gas simulation and has a negligible effect for the ideal gas simulation due to the different locations of instability onset. Notably, carbon species resulting from ablation are shown to slightly stabilize the flow for both cases. For the Reentry F flow conditions, inclusion of the ablating nose cone was shown to increase the region of second mode growth near the nose cone. Away from the nose cone, the second mode was relatively unaffected. Experimental and numerical results have shown that two-dimensional surface roughness can stabilize a hypersonic boundary layer dominated by second-mode instability. It is sought to understand how this physical phenomenon extends from an airflow under a perfect gas assumption to that of a flow in thermochemical nonequilibrium. To these ends, a new high-order shock-fitting method that includes thermochemical nonequilibrium and a cut-cell method, to handle complex geometries unsuitable for structured body-fitted grids, is presented. The new method is designed specifically for direct numerical simulation of hypersonic boundary-layer transition in a hypersonic real-gas flow with arbitrary shaped surface roughness. The new method is validated and shown to perform comparably to a high-order method with a body-fitted grid. For a Mach 10 flow over a flat plate, a two-dimensional roughness element was found to stabilize the second mode when placed downstream of the synchronization location. This result is consistent with previous results for perfect-gas flows. For a Mach 15 flow over a flat plate, a two-dimensional surface roughness element stabilizes the second-mode instability more effectively in a thermochemical nonequilibrium flow, than in a corresponding perfect gas flow.

Factors Affecting Transition at Supersonic Speeds

Download Factors Affecting Transition at Supersonic Speeds PDF Online Free

Author :
Publisher :
ISBN 13 :
Total Pages : 22 pages
Book Rating : 4.3/5 (91 download)

DOWNLOAD NOW!


Book Synopsis Factors Affecting Transition at Supersonic Speeds by : K. R. Czarnecki

Download or read book Factors Affecting Transition at Supersonic Speeds written by K. R. Czarnecki and published by . This book was released on 1953 with total page 22 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: This paper surveys the available material and summarizes what is known to date about boundary-layer transition at supersonic speeds. Variables studied include Mach number, Reynolds number, pressure gradients, heat transfer, surface roughness, and angle of attack. The discussion is limited to bodies of revolution because similar reliable data for wings is lacking.