Author : Paul Baron Miller
Publisher :
ISBN 13 : 9780494398968
Total Pages : 532 pages
Book Rating : 4.3/5 (989 download)
Book Synopsis Essays Toward a Theory of Fiduciary Law by : Paul Baron Miller
Download or read book Essays Toward a Theory of Fiduciary Law written by Paul Baron Miller and published by . This book was released on 2008 with total page 532 pages. Available in PDF, EPUB and Kindle. Book excerpt: Fiduciary liability is conventionally understood as premised upon the fiduciary relationship---the establishment of a fiduciary relationship gives rise to fiduciary duties, violation of which renders the fiduciary liable to the beneficiary. Implicit in the conventional view are two assumptions: the first is that the fiduciary relationship is a distinctive kind of legal relationship, and the second that certain of its distinctive qualities suffice to explain and justify fiduciary obligation. The conventional position has persisted for centuries despite the fact that these assumptions remain unjustified. Reams of case law and commentary have failed to yield a clear conception of the fiduciary relationship capable of securing its claim to distinctiveness. Likewise, the existence of a nexus between fiduciary obligation and the fiduciary relationship is largely taken as an article of faith. In recent years, the conventional position has been subject to challenge. Some have suggested that fiduciary obligation is justified directly on the basis of extrinsic moral, economic or policy goals (e.g., protecting trust, promoting economic efficiency). Others have argued that fiduciary obligation is ultimately contractual in nature, and may be explained and justified accordingly. In the end, both instrumentalist and contractualist theories of fiduciary obligation prove unconvincing. Nevertheless, a basic challenge remains valid: the assumptions implicit in the conventional position must be argued for. This thesis addresses that challenge. It seeks to vindicate the conventional position by securing the assumptions upon which it is based. To that end, I develop an account of the fiduciary relationship that articulates its distinctive qualities and shows how certain among them suffice to explain and justify fiduciary obligation. The resulting theory of fiduciary liability draws strength from the fact that it is built upon institutional practice and resonant with dominant private law theory.